Through to the start of the series, Casey and you may Rusty was indeed never most close as they stayed in two some other planets. Casey was most ashamed because of the her sibling. When Casey involved CRU, she never ever mentioned their sibling, Rusty. She indeed was not delighted as he made a decision to arrived at CRU, however, try prepared to put up with your and you will from time to time fulfill to possess a month-to-month brunch to catch up. Once Rusty found in order to her you to Evan cheated on her behalf and “defended the woman honor” because of the striking your on face that have a hope paddle, the pair of them agreed to ideal their dating and become part of for every single others’ lifestyle. They already been arriving at one another to have suggestions and you may consoled one to another when awful some thing taken place to each of them. Casey are happy to help Rusty that have dating and you can dating suggestions, however, she refused to let your with one thing of their intercourse lifetime. And in case he performed reach her getting suggestions about things sexual, Casey create rating Ashleigh to aid him since she is also uncomfortable into the topic. The actual only real time Casey got by herself associated with Rusty’s love life happens when she tried to prevent your out-of shedding their virginity so you can Lisa Lawson. She as well as attempts to include Rusty of delivering hurt emotionally while the viewed when she advised Ashleigh to not ever try him, unless she are sure of the lady intimate ideas toward your. Casey from time to time phone calls Rusty, “Russ” otherwise “Jiminy Cricket”. While Casey are enraged on him or attempts to get him to state whichever he’s covering up from the woman, she’s going to tackles Rusty since “Russell Allen”.
Cappie are Casey’s first love. It dated having six months from its freshman seasons and you will its ongoing feelings for each almost every other are a major spot line in the show. It first split while the Cappie forgot when planning on taking Casey to the newest Most of the Greek Baseball. On Pilot, it installed once Evan duped towards Casey, with Evan later accusing Casey regarding however being in like with Cappie. Immediately after Rusty informed Cappie that Casey was being loused by the Evan he consider he should try and you will profit her straight back, otherwise dissuade her out-of stating yes. So it ends up with them writing a newspaper along with her and you can kissing. Casey closes it down and actually leaves. In the second half of the earliest season even when Cappie is relationship Rebecca the guy however definitely keeps feelings to own Casey. They after return and relocate to Washington along with her.
Casey and Evan had been the advantage couple of Greek Line but infidelity and you can mistrust resulted in problem of the matchmaking. Casey plus dislikes Rebecca Logan through the a lot of season you to definitely because the she slept having Evan the original night of hurry. Through out the season, Casey manage name Rebecca slutty or generate responses for example “This will be regarding thinking that your sisters are nevertheless indeed there to you. That they’ll catch your after you slide, and you may believing which they will not be skanky nymphos who sleep which have the man you’re dating.” Evan and you may Casey split while the Frannie informed Evan one she persuaded Casey to keep which have your immediately after the guy duped. She also told your one to she doesn’t believe that Casey is over Cappie. This leads to a giant endeavor in which Evan vacation trips up with Casey, since the guy will not believe that Casey cares to possess your and therefore she did not make sure he understands concerning hug which have Cappie. Shortly after the breakup Evan de–loused Casey, and de-crowned the girl away from Omega Chi date. After Casey informs Evan within a party she continues to have attitude to possess him the guy realizes he likewise has thoughts on her behalf. Yet , he had been too-late and Casey the second day demonstrated up in the their home informing Evan you to she only desired to be family relations. Evan up coming uses all of those other very first season doing things he believes tend to victory the lady straight back. Instance getting household members together with her, giving Zeta Beta’s Mr. Purrfect champion Shane an a thousand dollar pay-off never to go out with Casey. Along with into the episode “A story away from A few Functions” Evan produces his little brother stick to “Casey Responsibility” which was focus on interference ranging from Casey and you can one child one she are speaking also. He later helps Casey research towards LSats. Frannie next manipulates Ashleigh towards the telling Shane out of,while the she already understands the key. Which following provokes Shane so you can informing Ashleigh just what most occurred. She essentially says to Evan which he needs to progress.